elderberries.com

elderberry, elderflower, and why they matter

elderberries.com header image 2

my first elderberry pie

February 16th, 2008 · 6 Comments

Today was a fun day… last week, I ordered some elderberries from Ulrich Young, who posted here a while back that he had elderberries available in Oklahoma. They arrived in great shape yesterday and were screaming to become a pie, some syrup, and some elderberry jam. The pie and syrup berries got their wishes today, but the jam will have to wait until tomorrow. I started by shining up the kitchen and laying everything out. (Let me add here I’m NOT a cook. I love to eat, but that enjoyment has never seemed to translate IMG_1149into cooking skill. I’m working on it, though.)

My first project was an elderberry pie. I went with the Autumn Fruits recipe since it looked simple and traditional, and since I didn’t feel like trying to make a pie crust. The first step was cleaning and de-stemming the berries, since there were still some small stems in the batch. I’ve read that the best way to get berries off IMG_1174stems when they’re fresh is to use a  fork and gently comb them off like hair, but with these stems being so small and soft from having been in the juice so long, it was a slightly more painstaking process. And did I say messy? It was a MESSY process. So messy, in fact, that I decided to get creative with all the juice as well and tie-dye a shirt with it. The shirt’s not done yet, though, so  I’ll save that for another post.

The pie itself was easy… IMG_1183fill the crust with elderberries, then pour sugar/flour/salt over that, add some lemon juice, put a top crust on, and bake. Of course, I say easy,  but when you end up keeping way too much of the juice as I did, you end up with a very runny pie. Note to self and others: the extra juice will not simply cook away, so be sure to strain berries well before adding them to the pie. Otherwise, you’ll get… well… you’ll see in the photos. (In my defense, this was my first pie.)IMG_1212

First I noticed that the pie oozed a lot of juice as it baked. It smelled good, but didn’t look so pretty, and I had to put a tin pan on the oven rack underneath it to prevent my oven from becoming a sticky, smoky, burnt elderberry mess from the drippings. On the inside, the pie was almost completely liquid. It had a good flavor, but it really wasn’t pie, so much as a fruity syrupy crusty berry thing that went well IMG_1228with whipped cream (my other failure emerged here when I realized I’d forgotten to buy vanilla ice cream). The texture of the pie was intriguing, as elderberries do have tiny seeds. The seeds are fine to eat, but they keep enough of their crunch to create an almost gritty feel when eating them. With this in mind, I’m betting an apple-elderberry pie would be delicious, using just enough apple to make the texture smoother.

I made elderberry syrup today too, and that was an entertaining experience as well, but I’ll save that too for another post.

(One last thanks to Ulrich of Oklahoma, who provided the elderberries for my recipe attempts. He has more and will ship, so contact him at robcrkranch@hotmail.com if you’re interested in ordering.)

Tags: food & drink · recipes

6 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Nisha B. // Feb 17, 2008 at 12:04 am

    wow… for first pie, you definitely went with a non-traditional one! as runny as it may look, thinking about a warm, berry filled crust sounds delicious. and i love the tie-dye idea! :)

  • 2 FRAN W. // Apr 14, 2008 at 9:00 am

    That is one funny looking pie, for sure!! It looks more like a pizza since I can not see the pan at all. Anyways, can’t wait till I get some berries to make one of my own. Thank you for this site and the contact with Ulrich. You are a godsend.

  • 3 Nancy // Sep 5, 2008 at 11:36 am

    Hey, use Tapioca for thickening.
    2 c. sugar
    1/3 c. Tapioca ground or pearl
    (or you could use flour)
    1 c. elderberry juice
    bring to a boil and cook til it thickens.
    put 4 c. elderberries in pie crust in pan
    pour thickening over top. add a little butter if you like.
    put top crust on with little cuts for air vent.
    bake one hour till crust is light brown.
    EAT.

  • 4 Mary-Ann Warren // Oct 11, 2008 at 8:09 am

    I was looking for a new recipe that wasn’t so runny and came across your story - way too funny!, and sounds oh so familiar! I’m going to precook my elderberries and thicken first this time, wish me luck!!!

  • 5 Chris Curlew // Oct 23, 2008 at 2:38 pm

    I have some elderberries in the freezer and I just peeled apples when I came accross your web site. A friend of mine gave me this tip….Pick your elderberries and put the whole stem and all in a paper bag and freeze overnight..the next day bring out of freezer and shake the bag..all the berries will have fallen off the stems!! I tried it for the first time this Fall and it is practically a miracle!!! No more tedious de-stemming of the berries…Good Luck!

  • 6 SHYRLAYNE GAJDZIK // Jun 21, 2009 at 11:39 pm

    I AM SEEKING TO PURCHASE AN ELDERBERRY PIE. MY BROTHER WILL BE HOME(OHIO) IN JULY, AND I WOULD LIKE TO SURPRISE HIM WITH ELDERBERRY PIE, JUST LIKE MOTHER USED TO MAKE. CAN YOU HELP ME?

    THANK YOU DO MUCH, SHYRLAYNE GAJDZIK

Leave a Comment